All practitioners should be familiar with the types of syphilis serology tests and their interpretation. Diseases caused by other treponemal organisms, including yaws, will cause the same serological reactions as syphilis.
Test for syphilis in all patients presenting with a genital ulcer. The ulcer (chancre) is characteristically a single indurated painless ulcer which can occur in the genital region or elsewhere on the body (extragenital).
In a patient seen for the first time with a clinical presentation that suggests primary syphilis do a NAAT (PCR) swab of the ulcer. In addition, syphilis serology should be requested.
Patients being treated for primary and secondary syphilis should have a rapid plasma reagin test (RPR) repeated on the day treatment is commenced to provide an accurate baseline for monitoring treatment.
In a patient seen for the first time for a STI check-up without any signs or symptoms of syphilis, request syphilis serology.
Pregnant and post-partum women should be tested for syphilis in accordance with WA Health recommendations. Testing for syphilis should also be offered at any stage in pregnancy if the pregnant person has been exposed to syphilis, had a new sexual partner, or if there is any concern that they have not received any of the recommended tests during the pregnancy.
Interpreting syphilis blood tests
Two types of tests are used for syphilis serology: non-treponemal tests and treponemal tests.
Non-treponemal tests
- RPR (monitors disease activity)
- Venereal Disease Research Laboratory (VDRL) test.
These tests do not measure antibodies to T. pallidum (the organism that causes syphilis). Instead, they measure antibodies to another protein called cardiolipin, derived from human cardiolipin, which has been modified by the treponemal infection so that it is perceived as foreign by immune surveillance. These non-treponemal tests are more likely to give false positive results than the treponemal tests because other disease processes can also modify human cardiolipin causing the same antibody development.
Both tests are quantified (they indicate how much antibody is present), so they can be used to monitor progress of infection or success of treatment. However, titres on the RPR and VDRL may be different, and cannot be directly compared.
VDRL is the only test fully validated for screening cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), although NAAT may be useful in the future.
Treponemal tests
- Enzyme immunoassay (EIA) – IgM and IgG
- Treponema pallidum haemagglutination test (TPHA)/Treponema pallidum particle agglutination test (TPPA)
These tests detect specific treponemal antibodies (commonly lgG) and, once positive, remain so whether the patient has been treated or not. Hence IgG detection in treponemal tests is not an indication of successful treatment. Proper interpretation of tests for syphilis usually requires a detailed history of the patient's illness, when they may have been infected, their treatment, and their previous test results. The history may come from the patient or from previous treating practitioners. The first test performed by the laboratory will be an EIA or TPPA or TPHA.
- If the result is negative, it is extremely unlikely that the patient has syphilis. However, in the first two weeks after infection, all tests may be negative, so:
- repeat syphilis serology in two to four weeks where primary syphilis or re-infection is possible, as other tests may become positive or the antibody titres may rise.
- If the result is positive, and the patient is not known to have been infected previously with syphilis, an RPR and other syphilis specific tests will be carried out. If the patient is known to have been infected previously, it is unnecessary to perform a FTA-Abs lgG.
If none of these follow-up tests is positive, the patient may have:
- a false positive TPHA, TPPA or EIA
- very early primary syphilis
- distant past syphilis that may have been treated or untreated.
If any of these follow-up tests is positive, this confirms the presence of genuine syphilis antibodies (meaning that the patient has the infection or has had the infection in the past). A positive RPR may be found in syphilis at any stage, whether or not the patient has been adequately treated. The most common situation in communities with long standing syphilis endemicity is that the clinical picture and serology are consistent with latent or tertiary syphilis, whether treated or untreated. If it is not certain that the patient has been adequately treated in the past, a full course of treatment is indicated.
Special considerations
- Clinical and CSF examination will determine the need for treatment of neurosyphilis.
- Neurosyphilis should be considered in seropositive patients:
- with neurological or ophthalmic signs
- with treatment failures
- who are HIV-infected
- who are unable to be treated with any form of penicillin
- with suspected congenital syphilis.
- Interpretation of CSF serology, protein level and cell counts should be discussed with a specialist.
- A chest X-ray is not recommended as a routine investigation for late latent syphilis. Full cardiovascular examination should be undertaken if patients have any cardiovascular symptoms.
Causes of false positive results in non-treponemal tests
- An acute false positive reaction occurs during or after various acute febrile illnesses (e.g. hepatitis, infectious mononucleosis, measles, malaria), pregnancy, immunisation and in one per cent of clinically normal individuals. The reaction disappears within six months. It is usually low titre.
- A chronic false positive reaction persists for more than six months. Such a reaction occurs in injecting drug users, autoimmune disease (e.g. systemic lupus erythematosus, immunoglobulin disorders), chronic infections (e.g. leprosy), and malignancy.
Causes of false positive results in treponemal tests
- TPHA/TPPA: Pregnancy, some viral infections (e.g. infectious mononucleosis), autoimmune diseases, cancer, injecting drug use and skin diseases.
- EIA: Causes are less clear, but include pregnancy, old age, some viral infections (e.g. infectious mononucleosis), autoimmune diseases, cancer, injecting drug use, and alcoholic cirrhosis of the liver.
Causes of false negative syphilis serology
- Antibody is not present. This is most likely in recently acquired infections, in which case the test should be repeated at least one month later. Recent antibiotic therapy may also delay the appearance of antibody.
- The patient is immunosuppressed.
- A negative RPR occurs in 25 per cent of patients with late syphilis. Therefore, EIA, TPHA or TPPA are the preferred screening tests.
- A negative RPR may also occur as the result of the ‘prozone reaction’ where the presence of a large antibody response in undiluted serum (as seen in some cases of secondary syphilis) overwhelms the test and renders it inaccurate. Asking the laboratory to retest with diluted serum overcomes this problem.
- If tests are negative in a patient suspected to have syphilis on clinical grounds, a specialist with appropriate experience should be consulted (see contacts for specialist advice on STIs and HIV).